Jennifer Niven continues to bring together two unlikely people with the characters of Libby Strout (the fattest teen in America) and Jack Masselin, who cannot recognizes faces. After years of Libby being home-bound (and losing hundreds of pounds) she reenters the world of public school, years after she had to be removed from her house by a crane. Libby has overcome her mother’s death and faces high school bravely and with a fierce sense of humor. Jack, always trying to fit in with those around him so that they don’t notice his moments of confusion at not recognizing his friends, remembers Libby from the night her house was taken apart so that an overweight girl could be lifted from it.
Now in high school, Jack gets caught up in a cruel game of ‘fat girl rodeo’ and he and Libby are linked together beginning with the prank and ending with group sessions and community service. Libby is brave throughout the story, hardly letting teasing affect her. She dances, has a quick wit, and knows people have seen the news story of her years ago, but doesn’t let it define her. Soon she is also the only one Jack has confided into about his Prosopagnosia disorder. An unlikely friendship for sure, but it is one with humor and support.
“We’re all weird and damaged in our own way. You’re not the only one.”
In the bravest move Libby could imagine, she proves to students – and herself – that she IS wanted, that everyone has insecurities, and that she is alive and present. She encourages everyone to be proud of themselves and dance! With a unique challenge/diagnosis pairing, the plot is original and really focuses on being true to yourself and loving what makes you – You! There is a lot of cussing in this one though which is why I have it as 14 or over.
I kept thinking of the title and wondered if ‘holding up the universe’ was the weight on Libby’s shoulders, or thinking back to her substantial weight gain after her mother’s death, but finally I think it’s about how everyone is connected. It’s a collective togetherness.
On a side note
– there is some backlash on the internet about Niven’s portrayal of obesity and the few moments Libby doubts her worth. Instead of focusing on those fictional thoughts, the more significant portrayal of Libby is one who is fiercely strong, funny, kind, brave, and happy. In the letter she writes to everyone/anyone, she gives worth to everyone, no matter their intelligence, size, race, or skill. Some also think her portrayal of a cognitive disorder is romanticizing mental defects and focuses too severely on prosopagnosia. Niven always researches for her books and writes in a respectful, profound, and delicate way. I’m sure, like every disorder there is a range of severity, and she focused on Jack’s as severe. As always though, this is fiction. Enjoy fiction and know the overall tone is one of kindness, being true to yourself, and seeing past the labels of high school.
As always, I love Jennifer Niven and find her writing beautiful and that the story is always worth reading.
“Dear friend, You are not a freak. You are wanted. You are necessary. You are the only you there is. Don’t be afraid to leave the castle. It’s a great big world out there. Love, a fellow reader”